How to Have a Conversation With Family That You Haven’t Had 100 Times Before
stay curious about the people you love while also getting your needs met
The fourth Thursday in November evokes a lot for me: love for my chosen family, memories of my family of origin at holidays, the waning of the year, delicious flavors, the things I did not finish yet this year, the beginning of saying “we’ll get to that in the new year” season, missing people who have passed on, gratitude for those who are here.
Oh and of course the 35 carbon copy conversations I’m going to dread having around the table. I’ve been temping and gigging for 2 years, and being asked for 50th time “so what are you doing now?” by my chosen sister’s new boyfriend is enough to make me head for the couch before dessert.
So how can we take all the good intention of [re]connecting, relaxing, and enjoying each other’s company and shift it away from repetitive, surface conversations (or, worse, hot button arguments that could probably just be played from a tape recorder at this point) and move it into something really interesting and energizing?
[Re] Discover Who People Are Now
I’ve been blessed to go through life with a pretty consistent chosen family for the past decade. Most years, I throw a big Friendsgiving, and I’m lucky to have a lot of chosen cousins who show up (and even do all the dishes)!
It’s easy to forget that just because people are familiar, I don’t necessarily know all there is to know about them. And, of course, the other classic pitfall we always run into is: “So, what are you doing now?”
Try asking questions that draw people in to telling you about their present experience and life today:
It’s been too long! Tell me what the highlights of your year have been/ [if relationship appropriate] what’s been tripping you up this year?
I can’t believe I haven’t seen you since spring! How have you been keeping yourself sane with everything going on?
I was just thinking of the time when you and I [memory]! It totally made me think of [present situation I’m dealing with] differently. How do you remember it?
It’s been a WILD year. What’s bringing you hope these days?
I heard you’ve been into xyz hobby this year, tell me about it! What do you love about it?
Did you have an adventures this year? I’d love to hear about what you’re up to!
As they answer, ask questions that keep the focus on their experience but don’t interrogate. Share back when you find a point of resonance like, “I totally feel you about taking walks in the park when the world gets too overwhelming.”
When you need to keep it light
There are definitely people and settings where we need to be careful about depth, or which topics we bring up.
A weird thing in both my chosen and original families is that we can all actually agree about certain topics, but sometimes things get uncomfortable anyway because some people want to talk about them really passionately, and some people want to just move on to other topics. It can feel like a minefield with conflicting wants and needs.
If in your conversations you feel activated, or things start to feel too heavy, here are some helpful course corrections.
Ask for what you need
A good formula is to: use “I” statements, say something positive but honest (gratitude is an easy go-to here for me), and then give a concrete exit to the conversation/ change the subject.
What you say will depend on who you’re talking to, but here are a couple ideas:
I feel differently about that, but I’m going to noodle more about what you said. I appreciate that we can talk about this sort of thing! Hey, by the way, I never asked— how did that date go with that guy?
Wow, I didn’t know I would get so emotional! Thanks for listening to me. I’m going to have some water and when I get back, maybe you can show me that cute rabbit video you told me about.
Share what feels comfortable
Maybe you want to connect with someone, but you’re unsure how personal you want to get. Or maybe you’d happily talk to them about something, but would rather not have everyone within earshot hear about it too.
You can choose something you’re happy to talk about and start there. Tell cousin Justin about the cooking class you tried, or the small victory you’re still feeling pretty pleased about. The most squishy, tender parts of your year can wait until you actually want to share them.
Try asking questions that give the other person that same choice: “What’s something you’ve been enjoying lately?” leaves plenty of room for them to talk about a new favorite snack or something more personal. As they answer, follow their lead on how much they want to share, while keeping your own comfort in mind too.
If the conversation moves toward something you’d rather not get into, you can acknowledge what they said and suggest another direction:
“That sounds like a lot to deal with. Would a distraction be welcome? I’ve been meaning to ask about your pottery class!”
“I’m still figuring out how I feel about all that, so I’m going to save that update for once I’m a little less messy about the whole thing. But I do have a totally ridiculous story about my week I need to tell you about!”
Give yourself permission to step away
Sometimes changing the subject doesn’t work, or you realize you’re ready for a break. It’s okay to leave a conversation without explaining everything you’re feeling.
A simple “I’m going to refill my plate” or “I want to catch up with Marika before she leaves” can be enough. If you’d like to pick the conversation up another time, you can say that too: “I’d love to hear more when we have a little more privacy. Can we catch up next week?”
Whether you’re spending the holiday with chosen family, family of origin, or a mix of both, you get to have a say in how you connect. Maybe this year you’ll learn something surprising about someone you’ve known forever. Or maybe you’ll laugh together over a ridiculous rabbit video while doing the dishes. That counts as catching up, too.